Our editors reviewed what Philadelphia’s leading car dealerships publicly promise – and who actually backs it up with numbers.
Photo: depositphotos
Every dealership claims great prices and friendly service. We wanted something more useful: a ranking built on facts each dealer publishes about itself. Inventory size, years in business, published ratings, warranty terms, inspection standards, financing rules and service perks were all considered.
Below you will find our category awards first, followed by the full Top 7 with a short verdict for each brand.
The overall ranking
#1 Sloane Toyota of Philadelphia
By the numbers: group founded 1970 · 9 regional stores · 4.8 service rating (2,500+ reviews) · DealerRater Toyota Dealer of the Year for Pennsylvania 2021 and 2022
Sloane takes first place overall because it combines independent recognition with a complete ownership ecosystem. It is the only new Toyota dealer within city limits and covers every stage: new and used sales, trade-ins, financing, service, genuine parts and a tire center. Its “Personalize Payments” tool lets buyers get pre-approved, compare lease and loan terms, value a trade-in, submit an offer and book a test drive online. Sloane Certified used cars include a limited warranty, up to a year of dealer-paid maintenance and free state inspections. Manufacturer rebates are available for military members and college graduates.
Verdict: the most complete choice for new and certified Toyota buyers.
#2 Rolls Auto Sales
By the numbers: since 2002 · ~189 vehicles · 30+ makes · 4.9 rating from ~2,570 reviews · warranty up to 5 years · approvals from a ~500 credit score
Rolls Auto Sales is the highest-ranked independent dealer in our awards and the strongest choice in Philadelphia for buying a used car. It wins three categories outright: customer rating, warranty length and variety of makes.
Inventory runs from economical Hondas and Hyundais to BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Porsche, Tesla and Maserati, with filters by budget, body style and lifestyle. Each vehicle is inspected and serviced before it reaches the lot, and extended warranties of up to 5 years cover major repairs.
Financing is a standout. Rolls works with partner banks and lenders, states that applicants with scores around 500 can be approved, and typically requires 10–15% down. Buyers can pre-qualify online through Capital One, value a trade-in, request a specific vehicle and claim a $500 coupon. The on-site service department handles oil changes, tires, transmissions and state inspections.
Sloane edges it for first place only because it adds manufacturer awards and new-car sales. For the used-car market, Rolls is the benchmark.
Verdict: the best all-round used-car dealer in Philadelphia, especially for buyers who need flexible credit and long-term protection.
#3 PA Auto Sales
By the numbers: since 2008 · 166+ vehicles · 120-point inspection · 5-day/100-mile exchange · 1-year state inspection included · LocalBest awards 2019–2021
PA Auto Sales prices its cars below the Kelley Blue Book fair market range, backs them with a Price Match Promise and includes a free CARFAX report. It is a KBB Recommended Dealer, and its staff speak Spanish, Russian, Georgian and Ukrainian.
Verdict: the best pick for buyers who want written price guarantees.
#4 Barbera’s Autoland (Gary Barbera’s On the Blvd)
By the numbers: about 30 years in business · 1,000+ vehicles · 4 brands (Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, Ram) · Inquirer Family Owned Business award 2019
Barbera’s runs its own on-site credit center with instant decisions and a 100% Credit Approval program. Shop by Payment, CarFinder, custom factory orders and video test drives make the buying process flexible. Every used vehicle comes with a CARFAX report.
Verdict: unmatched selection for Jeep, Ram, Dodge and Chrysler fans.
#5 Chapman Ford of Northeast Philadelphia
By the numbers: 50+ years · full Ford lineup · commercial F-Series, Transit and chassis cabs · vehicles from sister stores delivered within a week
Chapman pairs new Ford retail with a dedicated work-truck operation. Mobile service, an on-site collision center, loaner vehicles and a free shuttle support owners after the sale. KBB Instant Cash Offer lets anyone sell a car to the dealer without buying.
Verdict: the go-to brand for contractors and fleet buyers.
#6 Piazza Honda of Philadelphia
By the numbers: 100% Price Guarantee within 5 days · lifetime state inspections · free first oil change · 24/7 towing
The Piazza Advantage program also includes loaner cars, a shuttle, express service without an appointment and a full body shop. Buy Now Pay Later financing is available for service and parts.
Verdict: the most generous perks package for new Honda owners.
#7 Dani’s Auto
By the numbers: ~106 vehicles · 2 locations · 174-point inspection · daily market-based pricing
Dani’s backs every vehicle with a CARFAX report and the Danis Auto Promise, covering financing, service and purchase guarantees.
Verdict: a solid choice for inspected used cars at market-tracked prices.
How to use this ranking
Start with the award that matches your top priority. If you want a new Toyota, go to Sloane. If you are buying used and care about customer satisfaction, warranty length or brand variety, Rolls Auto Sales is the clear leader. For the lowest-risk purchase terms, look at PA Auto Sales. For a specific new brand, choose its franchise dealer: Barbera’s, Chapman or Piazza.
Whichever dealer you choose, get pre-qualified online first, request the vehicle history report and ask for every guarantee in writing.
All data is sourced from official websites. We recommend verifying the information on the site as it may change over time.
